Wednesday, February 22, 2012

End of Day 5 Summary: Where are If Vakuutus?

Ok so it is the end of Day 5 so where are we. Today is a day of two topics. Growth of support and then an absence of input from the other main player the big IF.

Lets start with the BIG IF

Well in the last reply i received from If Vakuutus they seemed to have accepted responsibility but did not want to act upon that. The customer is responsible for their errors apparently. As such this is still waiting and is once again at the top of their facebook group wall. I will not go away. Social media is easy it does not require much effort unlike standing outside their office with a loudspeaker. It also reaches alot more people. If have questions to answer and i want them to answer them publically.



Tomorrow i think i will write a little bit about what i think they are thinking but, for now that is where i will leave it. BTW this is the first week day that If Vakuutus have not responded. Does this mean that they have stopped communicating. Let's see.

Growth of Support

Over the last few days and again continued today we have seen growth in the number of followers. In this experiment i have also been learning by doing and as it is not a normal thing to try and get alot of folllowers quickly (at least for me) then i have done some things that i see are mistakes.

The biggest mistake i have made so far is to assume that if you follow a person they automatically follow you back or at least a large proportion (i am just nice like that). This is total rubbish and may work if you follow one person but when you follow many and have only a few followers you just appear as a "junk follower" it is just as bad as spam mail when you see twits from these people. As such i stopped and stopped following anyone who i didn't know or didn't follow me. You will now see my follows and followers are roughly in balance.

Furthermore to try and help to reach out to people in Finland i have also started to use Finnish language hashtags. One thing that i have learned through email marketing analysis is that people respond much better to content in their own language even though the body of the message may be in another language. Finns are pretty good at English although they often wont admit it so i am not worried on that score especially as those who are active in social media tend to be younger anyway. As such it means that my tweets are often tweeted now with English and Finnish tags.

Well this has meant that today i have now managed to reach 100 followers which i am honestly quite proud of because i have never had 100 followers before :-)

On the blog we have had record traffic today and with the exception of a slight blip on one day where we did not grow (i was not able to spend time at the computer that day and add that much content) we have continued to get more hits day on day.

The traffic is coming from all over the world but mostly Finland roughly 50% (the domestic market so to speak), the UK and the US (English speaking countries and very active with twitter in particular) and then a mixture of countries. We have also appeared on Russian blogs but i cannot read anything there so have no idea what they are talking about.


Today i also for the first time posted some video content. It was quite funny to watch but actually makes a serious point. This is not the first time this has happenned to If Vakuutus. They have been publically humilated and attacked previously and this is one of their videos. There are others.

I would love to hear from the guy in the video to hear his story and how that went. If you are out there make contact. I will look into that and get back to you. Interestingly this video received the most hits on the blog today and the most retweets. Comedy never hurt anyone. It may also have helped that the content was in Finnish though?

To continue with the video discussion, i can also say that i have now made my presence visible on the If Vakuutus YouTube channel where there televesion marketing material is held. They have quite a large push with television and radio advertising in Finland at the mo so check that out if you want to. As i was unable to add links in the comment boxes i have commented as my own YouTube channel which links to the blog and  @IFinsurancetwitter but that is currently being used only as a through channel and i will not actively promote it. You can get to the IF videos from it though if you are interested. I want IF to know that there is nowhere that they can hide in Social Media and if they will not engage me and answer my valid questions on Facebook then i will engage them whereever they are present in the electronic jungle.

Note i am NOT attacking them I am trying to Engage them. I have not bad mouthed or slandered them. I am just trying to bring this conflict to a justified end within a public space. I still want a resolution and my demands are in place so as to protect their other customers with ammendments to their terms and conditions and a review of some of their practices.

They must air their dirty laundry in public even if they do not want to.

Following Someone in the Hope they Follow You Is Not Good!

When i started the Twitter account four days ago i realised that i needed to try and get a lot of support quickly. One of the strategies i employed was to try and follow as many people as i could who i felt would be interested in the story, would support it by following themselves or even retweeting or were members of the Finnish media who may be interested.

If i had taken the time to read other blogs on the subject as i have done now i would have realised then that..

I was totally wrong!!!

All that i have done is reduce my own reputation on Twitter. It really does not look good to follow many more people than follow you. I think of the many people i have followed only a few have started following me.

Social media must be entirely voluntary, for people to follow you you must offer content that is valid for them and let them find it for themselves. All you can do is try and write content people are interested in and make it available to them on their terms. If they find you and want to follow you that is great. If they want to participate for themselves even better.

As such i as a policy will not follow anyone who does not produce content that i am interested in for this experiment or has followed me.

NO MORE JUNK FOLLOWING!! and SORRY

Please bare in mind i am learning as i go as i have never tried this kind of thing before and never had to generate large interest in something quickly.

P.S. let me know what you think about anything i am here to listen also!

Guess i am not the only person disatisfied with If Vahinkovakuutusyhtiö



View this from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xjVBdkT_7r0

The more i read about IF the more i realise why i am having to fight this battle. It is clear that i am not the first to try and fight IF.

Channel Performance Analysis

Well after four days i thought i would write something about how succesful the channels that i have been utilising in this endeavour have been.

As a recap the main channels i have created are:

A dedicated Twitter Account @IFinsurance (surprised i was able to get this user name)
A dedicated Facebook Group IF Vakuutus Social Experiment
This blog, no link required ;-)

The pre-existing channels that i am utilising are:

IF's Own Facebook Group. If Vahinkovakuutusyhtiö I am particularly trying to draw attention to mine and If vakuutus's conversation there.

As described earlier i plan to expand upon the utilisisation of If vakuutus's own social media later. Read on to understand why.

Twitter as a Channel

Prior to this experiement i was a Twitter user and had been for a few years. However admittedly i was that kind of user who was just a "follower" i was not a contributor other than the occasional retweet of content i found interesting. In all honesty i think that summarises most Twitter users. I used it as a way of getting up to date info about the things i was interested in, when i wanted it. On twitter there is always something new.

With this in mind i understandably did not have many followers around 50 of mostly people i already knew based upon around 300 tweets of my own (sorry retweets, the occasional tweet from services i had subscribed to and those that i had connected other social media to) Unsuprisingly then that my followers were low.

Just as a quick point i just do not get people who post things like "I just ran 30minutes hard via heia heia" Quite honeslty who cares! I don't even care about what my "real friends are doing". Anyway back to the point.

Well having started the new Twitter account @Ifinsurance for the sole purpose of publising this blog and story i am pleased i have been more succesful. For a while i did ponder if i should carry this out through my own @daniel_miles account but decided against it. I decided to have a campaign specific twitter account for people who just want to follow the story and not my other tweets. I also was afraid that i would annoy some of the followers of my personal Twitter account with the changed content of my account. So having balanced this against the advantage of already having a starting base of followers i decided to start from scratch.

So how has my new Twitter account performed.

Well with Just 100 tweets i managed to gain 75 followers in less than 3days merely by tweeting the story. This is 50% more followers than my personal Twitter account in roughly 1 3rd of the tweets and in 1% of the time. In this sense then i would certainly consider this a success if you were to measure this against my prior performance.

This has well been publisised else where in the blogosphere but Content is King, contributors get more followers! As well as just publising my story i have also tried to add content that may be relevant also to people who simply follow social media. Hence for example this post which has nothing really to do with the story with IF directly.

I have also managed to have the blog republished on other news sites each day. I have been retweeted countless times and have had several @mentions. I have also gained a couple of followers who seem to be pretty closely following me and retweeting a lot of what i tweet thanks for that!!

In this sense it seems i have managed to at least generate some interest among the twitter crowd. Further more by looking at the traffic statistics to the blog i can see that around 45% of the traffic has been coming from the shortened bit.ly type of link which indicates a lot of traffic from Twitter. More about the site traffic in the other sections.

On the whole then i have been pretty happy with Twitter as a channel, well at least based upon my previous experiences.

My Own Facebook Group.

This has been less of a success in terms of gaining members, i am now at 4 :-). I desribed my reasoning behind this in a previous post so won't go into it in too much detail here.

Generally though i felt that facebook groups needed to be known about and were better suited for companies than individuals as a channel to garner support for something.

In any case lookin at the traffic coming into the blog I can see that the top contributor for traffic has been facebook so although the Group has not gained members perhaps it has contributed to traffic. However i believe that the biggest contributor to the referring site was probably If Vakuutus's own Facebook group. See below.

If Vakuutus's Own Facebook Group

In my opinion this has been the best channel to utilise, even more so than Twitter. This is why,
  1. By Utilising If vakuutus's own social media and existing following you are able to piggy bag on If vakuutus's own success.
  2. By Utilising If vakuutus's own social media you are able to reach out to their own stakeholders. Who else would be on their social media?
  3. By having a constant presence there and maintaining your position at the top of their wall you are able to get a regular stream of traffic to your blog and to your story.
  4. By placing your content directly to If vakuutus's own facebook wall you are able to disrupt or interfere directly with their marketing messaging, branding and campaigning. This dilutes the power of their own social media as a tool and increases the risk and pressure upon them to act.
40% of Traffic is coming from Facebook and most likely alot of it is coming from If vakuutus's own group page.

The Success of My Own Blog

Well as i tweeted early i have now had more than 1000 visitors to the site so in that respect i am really happy.

The blog has been tweeted and shared directly from the blog in all, around 100 times so roughly 10% of visitors have spread the word further. Of course i cannot really tell how many times outside of my own social media the word has spread. I am sure though that for the 1000 visitors i have had many more have had some contact with the story even though they may not have visited the blog.

Coincidently i would like to know if If vakuutus's own traffic to their Facebook Group page has increased. I did note previously that they got 250 odd new members there after i started. This trend seems to have slowed now though.

Anyway i see the main strengths of the blog as:
  1. You can have a media that you can control and tell your own story.
  2. You have a single location where you want to drive traffic to (admittedly it is nice to drive traffic to the converation with IF also)
  3. If If vakuutus's decide to start boycotting me or deleting my posts from their social media then there is a complete record of the story outside of their control including the Facebook conversation with them. Deleting it does not make it go away. 
  4. If vakuutus cannot control this media, they can only contribute. BTW they are free to do so). It would be nice to see them trying to tell their story on my blog.
  5. Long after this story is dead people will still be able to find the blog. It will be a constant reminder to If vakuutus of this event. And who knows from time to time it will get retweeted, shared or even posted back on If vakuutus's wall. In this respect If vakuutus particularly should be aware and think how they should act. The degree to which this occurs i feel is dependent upon how If vakuutus react to it postively or negatively.
Summary of Basic Stats to Date (First 4 days)
  1. 1100 Blog Vistis
  2. Blog republished 4 times in other online news papers (that i know about, i was tweeted to be told)
  3. 40% of Traffic from Facebook and mostly likely If Vakuutus's own Facebook group.
  4. 45% of Traffic from Twitter or bit.ly type links
  5. 10% of Traffic from Direct Links implying they have saved the blog to their favourites
  6. 75 New Twitter Followers on the new account (gained 25 on my personal) 150 people following my Twitter media related to this then.
  7. Countless retweets and mentions and several avid supporters
  8. 45% or so of blog traffic coming from Finland despite the English Language.
  9. Only about 10% of Twitter followers are from Finland though interestingly.

    Tuesday, February 21, 2012

    End of Day Four Summary

    Well after actually not such an eventful day today in terms of actions. The blog has continued to attract traffic and we have increased the number of twitter followers again today by 50% or so. We also have been retweeted several times and again republished on other sites and the likes of the conversation with If vakuutus are increasing (like the post to get live updates and show support).

    We are continuing to grow and draw attention to the cause.

    The main news today was If vakuutus's response

    "I’m very sorry that you feel disappointed. However, that doesn’t affect the claims decision and the compensation line that we have – otherwise it wouldn’t be fair for the other customers in the same situation. I hope you understand this."

    Well I hope that the same situation never appears again (see what i have asked from If vakuutus below in my response).

    My whole argument has never been with their terms and conditions. They ARE pretty clear but my case is based upon the fact that they said they would cover it (or at least implied it was ok), we acted on that information at additional costs to ourselves and then they never paid.

    If have already accepted they were at fault for the miss communication (on Facebook) so it seems to me simply that.

    IF still want the customer to pay for their mistakes and shortcomings that they have already admitted.

    They did not seem to get this so i posted this very simply for them to understand..



    I also wrote a post today about how i felt that Finnish culture in particular influences this experiment. (sorry it is a long one i got a bit carried away)

    In short the conclusions are that Finns were not able to break away from their rule book to see an opportunity and to avoid the risks of continuing this course of actions. Something i feel is a characteristic of a lot of Finnish companies.

    Since If vakuutus have not taken the opprtunity to get a "great marketing story" then they are now in the realm of assessing what are the risks of continuing.

    This is much to my regret, because i wanted to show that customers could resolve their issues quickly and easily through social media... when there is a valid complaint. I do not want this to become a "hate" blog because i do not hate IF. The money involved is a principle thing. I have already spent much more time on this than it is worth to me personnally. I belive in social media. I belive in ethics and i believe that when consumers are being walked over they have options other than costly legal ones.
    I just find it hard to believe that If vakuutus will not pay for something they themselves have publically stated is their fault.

    Simply i believe that becuase this is a new situation for them and there is no precident or rule book to follow, other than the one that is in place i.e. there existing terms and conditions.

    It is ammusing that If Vakuutus would rather risk their reputation and continue to incur costs much above what the value of the original claim was (about 500 euros) than to get a fantastic marketing story for a bargain price and change the way they behave towards their customers.

    I think that they are worried about setting a precedent here for other persons with an axe to grind but in this situation there is a valid case and i have asked for actions to be put in place so that this wont happen again. In this respect i am actually giving them positive input for how to be better.

    For an insurance company that is all about risk assessment and assigning costs the ROI on this claim for If vakuutus must be horrendous. It makes absolutely no sense from them to continue with this from a financial point of view, a marketing point of view or from actually the ethical point of view.

    Tomorrow i will again post about my social media strategy, some statistics and evaluation of the channels and of course the daily update. See you then :-)

    Engaging Companies in Social Media Channels Politely Does Not Work

    Well after the latest If vakuutus's response it seems clear to me that If vakuutus have missed their opportunity to turn this into customer service and marketing success story. Something i wished that they had because this alone would have shown that social media has empowered the consumer and that companies have recognised this and have changed their behaviour accordingly. This has not worked.

    As such previously i was playing the role of a customer who was merely trying to communicate and engage with a company in a public channel with the hope that this combined with a growing support and interest base via this blog and the @IFinsurance twitter account would change their behaviour.

    In this Experiment: Using a company's own Social Media as a channel to engage a company does not guarantee success even with a valid case and a growing social media presence.

    As such a change in strategy is required so as to apply more pressure to If vakuutus through publicising the case and further damaging their brand image.

    I will continue to try and engage with people in Finland, the conventional media, persons interested in social media, the insurance industry and PR and Marketing Generally. I will do this primarily through Twitter @Ifinsurance.

    I have also expanded my use of Twitter. I decided that instead of just posting my own content i will redistribute content created by others writing about relevant subject material. I realise that social media is not only about pushing your own messaging but also spreading the word and collaborating with others. If i do not spread the message of others how can i expect others to spread my word. As such i have started a process of retweeting other relevant content via my twitter account.

    I will adopt a new strategy of Interference Against If vakuutus.

    Actually i am not sure if this is wise but i feel that at this point in time it is the only option really left to me. To try and increase the pressuse on IF i will interfere with their other customer dialogue on their own facebook group page and expand on this later to further increase the pressure if IF continue to resist.

    This is a risky strategy as i risk alienating my own audience. I hope that this is not the case.

    I have communicated very clearly with IF via their facebook wall what i hope to achieve and what will bring this to an end. If know what they need to do to stop this.



    I have started the policy of interference see IF vakuutus's Facebook group to start with....... more to follow if necessary.

    Please note i am not telling any lies about If vakuutus's, i will only post truthful comments. IF are very welcome to comment. I will continue to promote my own story via the blog. This is a very important fact, i do not want to do anything that could be conceived as slander. This is and always will be an entirely legal endeavour!!!

    My primary goal is to publisize my story and disrupt If vakuuts's own brand messaging through factual story telling and interaction with people who are posting on the IF Facebook group.

    I do not think that this is unreasonable. What do you think?

    You can get live updates of the conversation on the Facebook thread by liking it. http://t.co/JlbiA65M Liking will also show support. Comments of course also appreciated. Follow the conversation live also on Twitter @IFinsurance.

    The Human and Cultural Aspect

    Within this experiment there are other factors at play that have not yet been discussed. Namely the behaviour of the people involved in the experiement and in particular culture.

    Within the experiement there are 3 main players whose culture can have an influence on the experiement.

    Me and My Cultural Perceptions

    I am English, i have lived in Finland for 8 years. I have studied here worked here for Finnish companies and I during this time i have had relationships with Finnish women.

    Despite these experiences i am sure i still retain my English culture and still behave as such. However i do also have a unique view of Finnish culture and behaviour that Finns themselves (outside of academia) probably do not.

    As an English person or at least as me. I question things, i am passionate, if i get it into my head i am right i do not back down even though the "rules" in place suggest otherwise. I am not passive i am proactive and am not afraid to question, learn and improve myself. I am certainly not afraid to try things that others would not.

    In short i feel that these are not generally Finnish traits and i think that Finns and IF do not know how to deal with this as a Finn would not have done what i am doing. This is something new and i am not sure how the Finns will react inthis situation.

    Social Media and the Social Community

    Social media has helped globalise industries even though the companies themselves may be domestic. Finnish companies (with the exception of Nokia and the paper industry) generally have at least  80% of their business in Finland. People here ask why there has not been another Nokia "miracle". Is culture part of it? Is psyche part of it?

    Finnish companies may be even unaware that with the invent of social media and even the internet they are not just visible to Finns alone they become global even though their sales do not necessarrily follow suit. As a marketing professional it is important to maintain their brand not only in their own country but abroad and to all people who may have an interest (customers and stakeholders alike). By doing what i have done i am clearly putting IF onto the global stage. As such in this blog and on IF's wall i am communicating deliberately in English so as to evoke a wider interest than just in Finland. Finland only has a 5 million population that i can target. The globe has 7 billion and growing.

    In terms of the members of the social community who are participating in this endeavour their culture also pays a part. As we have had visitors from many countries it is difficult to apply cultural theory here.

    However from the data i can see that for example on Twitter most of the followers are from outside of Finland. However if i look at the traffic to the blog 50% is coming from Finland and 50% from outside.

    This says something about culture or at least the adoption of Twitter. Although Finns have visited the blog they have not subscribed or started to follow on Twitter. Instead they have chosen to remain anonymous and passive. Why? It could very well be that they totally disagree with what i am doing, a Finn would never do that ;-)

    Others who are following on the blog are commenting and sharing on twitter, retweating and liking on Facebook. If this is indeed conducive with If's responses and expectations and hence behaviour this would say much about my increasing frustration with them as perceived from my English perspective.

    Finns would not behave this way so they do not know how to respond effectively. They need to understand they are dealing with an Englishman who has different expectations from a Finn. I am their customer though and as such they should adapt to service my needs and expectations. Do they realise this?

    Finns and Finland

    As an English man i have much higher expectations for customer service than an average Finn.

    Finland is not an hierarchical society and in my opinion this in itself  means that Finns do not naturally accept a master and subordinate relationship. People here are always equal and that is the way Finns like it. In my opinion this has a detrimental affect on the level of customer service you receive here. The average Finn working in customer service considers the customer their equal, they do not naturally accept that they are there as a subservant in that relationship. I have experienced many examples of totally unacceptable customer service here, of course as perceived from my English perspective.

    It seems often to me here that the simple customer service principle "the customer is always right, even when they are wrong" has not been widely adopted in Finland. I think this is clearly demonstrated by this experiment and IF's responses. I should say here though that is not always that case, i have had excellent customer service in Finland. I will just briefly mention Iitalla who have given me excellent customer service in the past when they themselves have made mistakes with orders and faulty products.

    As an Englishman I am more likely than a Finn to interpret rules and apply them based upon the situation. This is often in combination to what we often refer to as common sense. This is especially valued when the rules in place do not apply to a situation, the situation has not been planned for or the whole thing is in flux. A metaphor for this could be that of a football referee (soccer for the Americans).

    The football referee has a clear set of rules that apply to the game. The rules are written to give clear black and white guidance that the referee is there to apply. Applying these rules word for word and perfectly will not make you a good referee.

    The referee is there also to control the game, violence, anger, the fans the players the coaches and at the top levels the media. If the referee fully applied the rules to every situation the game would very quickly get out of control. Top referees understnad this. They use common sense to apply rules where appropriate.

    For example:

    If we consider penalties. Many times i have heard, "if that was outside the box, it would have been a foul". That is true, but why was it not given, because the referee wants to control the game, avoid controversy. If he gave the penalty he would potentially affect the game, come in for criticism himself and lose control of the players and fans, especially if he was wrong. In this case the referee interprets when it is best to apply the rules and only does so when he is sure.

    When the foul is outside the box it means less in terms of effecting the outcome of the game so he is more likely to give a foul even when he is not sure that it is. This is especially true for example when there have been a series of strong tackles that have not technically been a foul. In this case the referee often blows to give a foul so as to regain control of the game and to calm the players down before a serious injury or bad foul does occur. In this case the rules are applied liberally.

    Other examples for the game are, players not getting booked early on in the game for a foul that would get them booked later in the game. Contact with goalkeepers, referees protect them to avoid controversy.

    As such a great referee knows when to interpret the rules and apply them to the situation and when it is appropriate to do so. In this way rules are interpretted, bent and applied to situations as appropriate. In this way at some level rules become guidelines and common sense is applied.

    In my opinion, Finnish culture does not readily adapt to what English people refer to as common sense. Finns like things nice and black and white they need a rule to apply to a situation to be able to resolve it. As such when a new situation occurs that their are no rules for or when the rules are not suitable finns will often continue to revert to the rule book instead of questioning it and using common sense to resolve the situation. This often causes problems for me personally in other walks of life when compromise and conflict resolution skills are required between parties. It is true that sometimes the rules get changed after the situation occurs so as to avoid the situation next time but for most part the situation acts as precident and the rules will be applied again in the future as in the first case.

    Through the media of this blog, i have communicated with IF, i have tried to describe their opportunities and risks early on in the experiment to them. They did not listen. I recognised this Finnish trait described above and i tried to influence them. I obviously failed. If are afraid of setting precident rather than measuring the risks and benefits in this unique situation that they probably do not have any specific guidelines or rules for.

    At this moment I have had getting on to 1000 visitors to the blog (and growing daily) as well as what i feel is a valid argument for challenging the claim. In response to If i have clearly outlined what i expect from them and how i wish them to respond so that they can have a framework to work with. Let's see what happens. Next

    Conclusion

    Characteristically of Finns, in the eye of criticism or conflict they shut down, become defensive stop listening and stick to their guns no matter what.

    I am sure that this post in itself will prompt at first a negative reaction from IF and the Finns reading this. If will want to stick to their guns.

    I am writing this though as i feel it is valid for the experiment and should be written even though it will probably have a detrimental affect on the outcome from the point of view of changing IF's mind about overturning the claim.

    This is after all an investigation into the effectivenss of social media to empower individual customers against organisations and as such it would be foulish to ignore this content as a variable.

    However Finns have one more interesting characteristic they seem to be very interested in what people think of them and Finland. I hope that this characteristic will counter act any hostility that may be felt and people of all nationalities will read this and think and maybe change their own behaviour.

    Culture is a major factor that affects all business everywhere and in my opinion is often neglected or underestimated.
    You can get live updates of the conversation on the Facebook thread by liking it. http://t.co/JlbiA65M Liking will also show support. Comments of course also appreciated. Follow the conversation live also on Twitter @IFinsurance.